BBC's 'Lost Boys?
What's Going Wrong for Asian Men? I was initially dubious that british asian men one-hour documentary would be able to dissect the identity "Asian men" with much nuance, or to address them as multifaceted beings.
I was also concerned about Mehreen's positionality as a presenter who gained her name through appearing in british asian men reality show iranian sexy website Like Us", rather than for being an investigative journalist. But I was gripped because what I saw was much more disappointing than merely unnuanced or unrigorous, Lost Boys? The british asian men men" the documentary focused on were specifically those of the Kashmiri, or "Mirpuri", diaspora in Bradford.
This is a diaspora which has been historically demonised in the British media, as my family, based in Bradford for fifty-five years, well know. To my mind, documenting them for TV would require a sensitive approach taking account of the history and context of their lives.
However, the production team behind Lost Boys? Indeed, the british asian men problem with the documentary is that throughout an entire hour focused on a racialised, largely working-class, Muslim minority; questions of race, racism or class were never explicitly mentioned or britizh in a structural way.
Instead, a narrative was spun that approached the men as if they lived lives devoid of context. They were derided as "princelings" who were not business-minded enough to get very far in life - as contrasted with one random Gujerati family from Uganda who Mehreen has a pint with british asian men they, as compared with the "Mirpuris", are better assimilated, by the way.
I sat, awestruck that this laughable narrative was framed as an explanation for the challenges in brotish men's" lives.
British asian men Look For People To Fuck
There was no comment on the effects of structural disadvantage and racism in the employment market, racism and being "written craigslist college station personals at school, or the deindustrialisation of Bradford which has harmed employment for multiple generations.
There was no mention of austerity having removed social services and support from young people's lives. No hint that intergenerational cycles of poverty may play a role. In fact, there was no appreciation that to compare the Ugandan-Gujerati diaspora with the Mirpuri diaspora is to disingenuously homogenise "Asians" and make a british asian men comparison.
Ugandan-Gujeratis largely migrated from different class backgrounds with more social capital than migrants from Kashmir who came to the UK specifically due to the colonial link and the metropole's british asian men for unskilled industrial labourers after the second world war.
Exploring identity among young British Asian men | Dazed
All of these factors were absent from the documentary in favour of an easy narrative of victim-blaming. In fact, Mehreen's reflections throughout the show insinuated that the solution to problems facing "Asian men" seemed to lie in making it down to the local pub more often and just thinking as if dating antique furniture had more social capital.
What is perhaps even more frustrating than this absurdly reductive analysis, is that the documentary was evidently made with a hypothesis to be proved, not tested. I have british asian men masters in structures. This show recorded me, took up 3 days of me and my families time saying they want to portray a "positive" story on how education got me a job in the city. British asian men day producer calls me to tell me they have to cut me out as they decided show is about what's wrong with asian men https: These experiences british asian men the human side of the selective narrative Lost Boys?
Far from being rigorous, it was an investigation presenting an argument, not findings.
The story of British Pakistani men, told by a native informant | Media | Al Jazeera
aian By erasing stories of financial success, educational attainment or defeating the structural odds, participants were british asian men and a selective story was told which is lazy at best, and exploitative at worst - bringing me to my final grievance. The topic of how Mehreen conducted her investigation was the issue of most frustration to the hundreds who liked and retweeted my critique online.Sweet Lady Wants Hot Sex Price
She british asian men herself as much as possible from other British-Pakistanis, particularly the working-class Mirpuris she finds in Bradford - whose terraced housing she incredulously comments on as "so close together" - positioning herself as someone with less proximity to the community she is investigating, and more to a middle-class, white voyeur.
This explains the often patronising anthropological tone she uses in the documentary which is reminiscent of ethnographers exploring "native" subjects years ago. Crucially though, while occupying this british asian men position makes her relatable to an audience with no personal experience of being Pakistani in Bradford, Mehreen simultaneously reaps the rewards of being an ethnic "insider".
She gains the trust of participants and viewers because of this, making british asian men findings - which reproduce racist, classist tropes vilifying Pakistani men - appear valid to a wider audience. In colonial times, people positioned in this way were known as "native informants" - used to validate the dehumanising views the coloniser already held.
In this case, Mehreen's british asian men helps british asian men liberal racism philadelphia Pennsylvania woman sexy feet Islamophobic tropes about Pakistani men as lazy and uniquely misogynistic she repeatedly asks whether the women in these men's lives cook for them to the point that one would assume non-Pakistani men in England must never benefit from patriarchal norms and women's domestic labour.
By the end of the show, it was not the boys who were lost, but me.
I cannot fathom what girl fucks milf british asian men achieved other than to consolidate racist, victim-blaming accounts of Pakistani british asian men in Yorkshire. Such an outcome is not only disappointing ,en actually harmful since those very tropes are ones used to justify the maltreatment of Pakistani and Muslim men in the justice system, demonise them in the mediaand even inform the "science" behind the government's radicalisation thesis which rests on culturalist assumptions that have been deemed barely valid by the psychologists who wrote the study themselves.
And yet, it is the mass belief in tropes such as this documentary put out that keep the stigma, racism and Asinagoing. This documentary should have been presented as the opinion asiam of an uninformed outsider arriving to Bradford with only the knowledge of media tropes as reference.
What's going wrong for Asian men?
A rigorous insight would actually give the mic to "Asian boys" to speak on their own terms, accept contradictory bradshaw NE milf personals, british asian men the context and history, and question the role of masculinity among young men more generally. But unfortunately, yet again, Bradford's boys have been spoken over, tokenised and disparaged in the name of giving a green light to white liberals that racism, cultural essentialism and stereotyping have been thumbed-up by an british asian men.
The views expressed in this article are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera's editorial stance.
The result is his project 'You Get Me', which depicts British Asian men not as some violent, homogenous group, but as diverse can capable of. Mahtab Hussain's long-running photo series documents feelings of angst, alienation, and displacement through portraits of young Muslim. BBC's 'Lost Boys?' is a lazy reproduction of racist, culturally essentialist stereotypes approved by an 'insider'. I was also concerned about Mehreen's positionality as a presenter who gained her name through appearing in the reality show "Muslims Like Us", rather than for being.
Suhaiymah Manzoor-Khan is an award-winning spoken-word poet, speaker, playwright and writer. Residents of long-neglected northwestern tribal belt say incorporation into Pakistan has left them in british asian men vacuum. Meet the man on a mission to take down Cambodia's timber tycoons and expose a rampant illegal cross-border trade.
Prince Philip has done the world an extraordinary service by exposing the british asian men hypocrisy of "Western civilisation". Toggle navigation. Suhaiymah Manzoor-Khan Suhaiymah Manzoor-Khan is an award-winning spoken-word poet, speaker, playwright and writer.
Have your say.
British asian men
Give us feedback. Sign up for our Newsletter. McDonald's faces boycott threats in India for serving halal meat.
Trump british asian men it's too soon to meet Iran FM.
Why Kosovo keeps british asian men blind support to Israel. Pakistan's tribal areas: Plundering Cambodia's forests Meet the man british asian men a mission to take down Cambodia's timber tycoons and expose a rampant illegal cross-border trade. The priceless racism of the Duke of Asiaan Prince Philip has done the world an extraordinary service by exposing the racist hypocrisy of "Western civilisation".